Umpires can make mistakes, occasional human errors are acceptable. But the process of making a logical decision cannot be mistaken. It is not acceptable for an umpire to consult the fielding captain alone and rule a batsman out. It makes one wonder about the role of third umpire and why the batsman does not deserve a consideration in decision making. BCCI must take up this issue with ICC and make sure that at least from now on proper procedure would be followed in umpiring decisions.